Defining logic to be so broad that any cause/effect is logical rids the usefulness of the term. The idea of removing emotion in favor of logic requires logic, but at this stage there is no inherent reason to favor logic, so the idea is a contradiction.
It’s trying to construct the definitions of the premises in a way that will force the foregone conclusions. The definitions then need to be justified within that framework, or it’s baseless.
A framework must define itself.